Wednesday, 14 October 2015

A Tale Of Two Abortion Laws

Scotland didn't win the independence vote during the referendum because people believed the new devolution powers will give the government a shot at staying in the UK and avoiding a host of problems with sovereignty.



With new powers comes duplicates of laws devolved for the Scotland government's personal use. However, this is necessary, according to Scottish Secretary David Mundell. He said there's no "convincing constitutional reason" why the move should not move forward.

One of these is the abortion laws.

Hasty Devolution

Abortion traffic is a primary concern among Scottish politicians. As Britain's own rules increase the difficulty of obtaining standard abortion services, Scotland's new laws will increase this traffic and increase the cross-border problems of the country.

Women and human rights organizations said the adoption of new abortion laws may be a hasty devolution of Scottish laws. The government is also warned that it could create a "differential and discriminatory impact on women and girls in Scotland."

End of Life Issues    

According to Mundell, the Scottish Government has the right to deal with end of life issues. With powers extending to the NHS and criminal justice in Scotland, abortion law, even if a duplicate of Britain's own laws, is Scotland's own laws.


“I do not see a convincing constitutional reason for why abortion law should not be devolved and that is what has led me to this decision. What will follow is proper engagement with interested parties as we take this matter forward," he said.

No comments:

Post a Comment